Dispatch · Explainer

What Is a StingRay? Cell-Site Simulators and the Secrecy Around Them

The device finds a phone by pretending to be a cell tower. For years, the agreements that came with it told police to hide that it was ever used, even from judges.

A StingRay is a cell-site simulator: a portable device that imitates a cell tower so nearby phones connect to it, letting police locate a specific phone. “StingRay” is one product name that became shorthand for the whole category. What ties it to parallel construction is not the radio. It is the paperwork: FBI nondisclosure agreements that told local police and prosecutors to keep the device out of court, up to and including dropping a case.

Key takeaways

  • Cell-site simulators pose as cell towers. Phones in range connect to them, which lets police pinpoint a target phone and also sweeps in bystanders' phones.
  • An FBI agreement released in 2015 after a New York Civil Liberties Union lawsuit let the FBI seek dismissal of a case rather than disclose the technology.
  • A Baltimore detective testified in 2015 to about 4,300 uses since 2007 (AP, Apr. 2015).
  • Since Sept. 2015, Justice Department policy generally requires a warrant for federal use. That policy does not bind state or local police.
  • Maryland's second-highest court held in 2016 that police need a warrant, and a federal judge suppressed StingRay evidence the same year.

01What a cell-site simulator does

Your phone constantly looks for the strongest nearby tower. A cell-site simulator exploits that habit. It presents itself as a tower, and phones within range connect to it instead of the carrier's network. The Electronic Frontier Foundation describes the result plainly: police can locate a phone more precisely than a carrier can, and the device logs the identifier tied to every SIM card in the area, not just the suspect's.

That second point matters. A cell-site simulator is not aimed like a rifle. It works like a net. EFF notes that the sweep can capture phones in homes and doctors' offices nearby, and that the devices can disrupt nearby calls, including calls to 911.

You will see the devices called StingRays, IMSI catchers (after the International Mobile Subscriber Identity number on a SIM card) or cell-site simulators. They mean the same category of tool. Court records from Baltimore describe the police department buying its equipment from the Harris Corporation, and EFF links much of the secrecy around these devices to nondisclosure agreements with that company.

Scope note. We describe what these devices do at the level courts and civil liberties groups describe it. We do not publish technical details. For know-your-rights material, see EFF's Street Level Surveillance guide.

02The nondisclosure agreements

Local police did not just buy these devices. In many places they signed agreements with the FBI first. The agreements are the reason this technology belongs on a site about parallel construction.

In April 2015, after a lengthy court fight, a New York judge ordered the Erie County Sheriff's Office to release its FBI agreement to the New York Civil Liberties Union. As MuckRock reported on April 8, 2015, the six-page agreement allowed the FBI to seek dismissal of a criminal case rather than reveal details of the cell phone tracking, if the FBI decided disclosure would compromise the technology.

Baltimore had a similar arrangement. Maryland's Court of Special Appeals described a 2011 agreement between the Baltimore City State's Attorney and the FBI, tied to the police department's purchase of the equipment, that barred disclosing information about it, including in court documents and hearings (State v. Andrews, Md. Ct. Spec. App., March 30, 2016).

Other reporting describes what that secrecy looked like in practice. EFF's guide lists prosecutors accepting plea deals or dropping cases to avoid disclosure. Human Rights Watch's 2018 report “Dark Side” says the FBI reportedly required local police to use “independent” means of investigation so the device's use would not come out.

What the record doesn't show

The agreements show what prosecutors were told they could do. They do not tell us how many cases were dismissed, pleaded out or rebuilt to keep a cell-site simulator out of court. We have not seen a public count, and we won't estimate one.

03Baltimore: about 4,300 uses

The clearest window into scale came from a courtroom. In April 2015, a Baltimore police detective testified under oath that the department had used a cell-site simulator about 4,300 times since 2007, according to the Associated Press.

One of those uses became the leading case. On May 5, 2014, Baltimore police used the device to locate Kerron Andrews inside a residence. The evidence found there was later suppressed, and the Maryland appeals court held that this kind of use requires a warrant (more on that below).

The 4,300 figure is one detective's sworn estimate for one city. It is not a national number, and nobody has published a reliable one.

04Why this is a parallel construction problem

Parallel construction means giving a hidden investigative method a clean replacement story. A cell-site simulator that must never appear in court is a hidden method by definition. If police find a suspect with the device and then describe the arrest as the product of a tip, a surveillance team or a lucky stop, the defense has nothing to challenge. The judge has nothing to rule on.

That is exactly the problem the Maryland court named. It said the nondisclosure agreement kept the court from performing its constitutional duties, and it called the State's conduct “inimical to the constitutional principles we revere” (State v. Andrews).

For the broader legal picture, read our dispatch Is Parallel Construction Legal? The homepage's techniques section places StingRay concealment beside the other methods documented so far.

05The Justice Department's warrant policy

On Sept. 3, 2015, the Justice Department announced a department-wide policy on cell-site simulators. Its main terms:

IssueWhat the policy saysWhat it leaves out
WarrantAgents generally need a warrant based on probable cause.Exceptions for exigent circumstances and certain “exceptional” cases.
DataWhen locating a known phone, collected data must be deleted once it is found, and at least once a day.Compliance is checked through an agency-level audit program.
ContentDevices may not be used to collect the contents of communications in criminal cases.Binds Justice Department components only.
Who it coversDOJ components (including the FBI and DEA) in domestic criminal investigations.State and local police, who are covered only by their own state's law and courts.

The announcement does not address what prosecutors must tell courts or defendants about past use. A warrant requirement and a disclosure requirement are different things.

06What courts have said

  1. March 30, 2016 · Maryland

    State v. Andrews

    Maryland's Court of Special Appeals held that police need a warrant based on probable cause, or an order meeting warrant requirements, to use a cell-site simulator unless an established exception applies. It affirmed suppression of the evidence, and held the good-faith exception did not save it. Opinion.

  2. July 2016 · Federal court

    United States v. Lambis

    U.S. District Judge William Pauley suppressed evidence the DEA found after using a cell-site simulator to locate a drug suspect's apartment. The Christian Science Monitor reported it as the first time a federal judge had suppressed evidence obtained this way.

  3. Sept. 2026 · Fourth Circuit

    Andrews's civil suit

    In Andrews's lawsuit against Baltimore police, a Fourth Circuit panel held that using a cell-site simulator is a Fourth Amendment search that requires a warrant. It still ruled against him: the detectives received qualified immunity and the department was not held liable, The Daily Record reported on Sept. 28, 2026. The paper also noted that Maryland had written a warrant requirement into state law in 2020.

The pattern is familiar. Courts can say a practice was unconstitutional and still leave the person it was used on without a remedy. And none of these rulings could happen until the device's use came out.

07Questions to raise with a lawyer

If you or someone you know is facing charges, these are questions to bring to the defense attorney. They are not a strategy, and only your lawyer can decide what fits your case. The homepage's Fight Back section has more.

  1. How, specifically, did police find my phone or my location on the day of the arrest?
  2. Was a warrant or court order issued for location tracking, and did it tell the judge what technology would be used?
  3. Has discovery produced the full chain of how agents first identified the phone number involved?
  4. Did any agency involved sign a nondisclosure agreement covering surveillance equipment, and could that affect what we've been given?
  5. Does the timing of the arrest or stop line up with the investigative steps described in the reports?

08Frequently asked questions

Is a StingRay the same thing as a cell-site simulator?

Yes, in everyday use. StingRay is a product name that became shorthand for the whole category. Cell-site simulator and IMSI catcher describe the same kind of device: one that imitates a cell tower so nearby phones connect to it.

Do police need a warrant to use a StingRay?

It depends on who is using it and where. Justice Department policy since Sept. 2015 generally requires a warrant for federal agents, with exceptions. Maryland courts have required one since 2016, and a Fourth Circuit panel held in 2026 that using the device is a Fourth Amendment search. Other states differ. Ask a lawyer about your own jurisdiction.

Does a StingRay affect people who are not suspects?

Yes. According to EFF, the device collects identifiers from every phone in range, not just the target's, and can disrupt nearby calls. That is one reason courts and civil liberties groups treat it differently from an ordinary location request to a carrier.

Would a defendant be told if a StingRay was used to find them?

Not always. FBI nondisclosure agreements released in 2015 told local agencies to protect the technology, including by seeking dismissal of a case rather than revealing it. Whether use is disclosed in a particular case depends on the agency, the jurisdiction and what defense counsel asks for.

Can a cell-site simulator read text messages?

Justice Department policy bars federal agents from using these devices to collect the contents of communications in criminal cases. EFF reports that some models may be able to reach content under certain conditions. The federal policy does not govern state or local police.

Case tips

Know a case where the location story doesn't add up?

Send us the court, the docket number and the filings. We build every case file from public records and correct our own work. Defense attorneys looking for research can write to legal@parallelconstruction.org. If you are the person charged, talk to your own lawyer before sharing anything about your case with anyone, including us. Messages to us are not privileged.

09Sources

Every fact in this dispatch comes from the documents below. If you spot an error, tell us and we'll correct it on this page.

  1. Electronic Frontier Foundation, “Cell-Site Simulators / IMSI Catchers,” Street Level Surveillance
  2. MuckRock, on the release of the Erie County Sheriff’s Office’s unredacted FBI StingRay nondisclosure agreement, Apr. 8, 2015
  3. Associated Press via PBS NewsHour, “Baltimore police often surveil cellphones amid U.S. secrecy”, Apr. 2015
  4. State v. Andrews, No. 1496, Sept. Term 2015 (Md. Ct. Spec. App. Mar. 30, 2016); see also EFF case page
  5. U.S. Department of Justice, “Justice Department Announces Enhanced Policy for Use of Cell-Site Simulators”, Sept. 3, 2015
  6. Christian Science Monitor, “Federal judge declares evidence from cellphone tracker unconstitutional”, July 14, 2016
  7. The Daily Record, “Police need warrant for cell-site simulators, 4th Circuit rules”, Sept. 28, 2026
  8. Human Rights Watch, “Dark Side: Secret Origins of Evidence in US Criminal Cases”, Jan. 9, 2018

Keep reading

Public education, not legal advice. We are not attorneys. If you are facing charges, talk to your lawyer before sharing anything about your case with anyone, including us.